Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

Should I invest in a British ISA?

The announcement of a new ‘British ISA’ in the UK government’s Spring budget has been characterised by some analysts as a fresh boost for savers. The new initiative would boost the existing ISA allowance by a further £5,000, helping savers keep more of their money. The UK government says the objective of the British ISA is to “support a culture of investment in the UK.” But critics have attacked the chancellor’s savings scheme as “doomed to fail.” The debate has left some wondering, should I invest in a British ISA? 

What is the British ISA? 

Officially known as the UK ISA, the new savings account provides tax advantages which protect income which arises from the account from income tax and capital gains tax. It will come as an addition to the existing four adult ISA schemes in the UK, which are the Cash ISA, Stocks and Shares ISA, Innovative Finance ISA and the Lifetime ISA. Put together the yearly limit across all ISA types is £20,000. The new British ISA would expand this limit by a further £5,000 and according to the government “provide a new tax-free savings opportunity for people to invest in the UK, sitting alongside a wider package of measures.”

When will the British ISA become available? 

The government has yet to provide a date for the creation of the ISA, the implementation of which is set to first go under a public consultation. The government has said the consultation period will end on June 6, 2024 and has signalled it would be particularly keen to hear from UK companies which could stand to benefit, ISA managers, industry bodies and other relevant parties. 

According to This is Money, the earliest likely launch date of the British ISA would be April 2025, after the general election.

Is the British ISA worth investing in? 

The British ISA was heralded as a ‘step into the future’ by The Financial Times, saying the move represented an effective expansion of the existing ISA allowance by 25 per cent, which could benefit as many as 800,000 UK citizens. They add that the condition that the £5,000 be invested in UK equities could contribute toward a reversal in money being withdrawn from UK equities.

However, the IFA Magazine said the scheme was ‘doomed to fail’ in its objective to boost UK equities, and said only a small number of savers would be eligible to benefit from the extraallowance. Speaking to the outlet Michael Summersgill of AJ Bell branded the British ISA as ‘ill-conceived and politically motivated’. He said: 

“Increasing investment into UK companies is a laudable aim, but this ill-conceived, politically motivated decision will simply not achieve that objective.

“50% of the money our customers currently invest through their stocks and shares ISAs is invested into UK assets, so this new allowance will have no impact whatsoever on their investment behaviour.

“A tiny minority of people max out their £20,000 ISA allowance each year, but these are the only ones that will see any benefit from the additional British ISA allowance. In the context of the £2tn+ UK stock market, any additional investment generated by these investors through the British ISA will be a rounding error.”

In a separate article by FT Adviser, investment editor David Thorpe warned against the “unintended consequences of the British ISA.” Thorpe raised concerns, including how ‘British assets’ would be defined under the scheme – but did temper his critique by pointing out that the British ISA remains in the consultation phase.

Investors Chronicle were more optimistic about the British ISA, saying that while it might not solve UK stock market woes, it could do something to help. Speaking to the outlet, Darius McDermott of Chelsea Financial Services said the allowance boost would be a “great way to help support our savers on their long-term investment journeys.”

What are the four different ISAs? 

There are four main types of ISA in the UK, each catering to different saving goals and risk tolerances:

1. Cash ISA: Cash ISAs are similar to regular savings accounts but with the added benefit of tax-free interest. They are suitable for individuals who prefer low-risk investments and want easy access to their savings. Cash ISAs are ideal for short-term goals, emergency funds, or as a way to preserve capital.
2. Stocks and Shares ISA: This type of ISA allows individuals to invest in a wide range of assets, including stocks, bonds, and mutual funds, within a tax-efficient wrapper. Unlike Cash ISAs, Stocks and Shares ISAs carry higher risk but offer the potential for higher returns over the long term. They are suitable for investors with a higher risk tolerance and a longer investment horizon.
3. Innovative Finance ISA (IFISA): IFISAs enable individuals to invest in peer-to-peer lending platforms or crowdfunding projects within a tax-free ISA wrapper. These ISAs offer the potential for attractive returns by lending money directly to individuals or businesses. However, it’s important to note that peer-to-peer lending carries risks, including the potential for borrower default.
4. Lifetime ISA (LISA): Designed specifically to help individuals save for their first home or retirement, LISAs offer a government bonus of 25% on contributions, up to a maximum of £1,000 per year. Individuals can contribute up to £4,000 annually, and funds can be used to purchase a first home or withdrawn tax-free after the age of 60 for retirement. However, there are penalties for early withdrawals for purposes other than buying a first home or retirement.

By understanding the different types of ISAs available, individuals can choose the most suitable option based on their financial goals, risk appetite, and investment horizon, ensuring they maximize their savings in a tax-efficient manner.

How is the British ISA different? 

The British ISA is designed to encourage investment in UK businesses and to help provide a boost to the stock market. This means that the additional £5,000 allowance must be invested in UK companies as part of the scheme. Savers are incentivised to put their money in a British ISA because of the tax free allowance associated with it.  

The Times Money Mentor notes this incentive could go further than just boosting stocks, but also provide support to the UK financial services industry. But they point out that given UK stocks comprise just 4 per cent of the global market, the stipulation could prove limiting.

The current proposals would include investments in corporate bonds, gilts, collective investment vehicles and ordinary shares would be eligible, subject to the outcome of the consultation – as long as they meet the yet-to-be-defined criteria for qualifying as a British investment.

 Is the British ISA worth it? 

The introduction of the British ISA could present both opportunities and challenges for savers looking to maximize their tax-efficient savings. The proposed increase in the ISA allowance by £5,000 aims to provide a new avenue for investors to support UK businesses and potentially stimulate the stock market. However, amidst the optimism, there are concerns raised by critics regarding the efficacy and potential limitations of the scheme.

While proponents see the British ISA as a step towards boosting investment in UK equities and supporting the domestic economy, sceptics argue that its impact may be limited, benefiting only a small proportion of savers. The debate surrounding the British ISA underscores the importance of careful consideration and understanding of its implications for individual investors.

Amidst the discussion of the British ISA, it’s essential not to overlook the existing options available within the ISA framework. Cash ISAs, Stocks and Shares ISAs, Innovative Finance ISAs, and Lifetime ISAs offer diverse avenues for tax-efficient savings, catering to varying risk tolerances and financial goals.

Ultimately, the decision to invest in a British ISA or any other type of ISA should be informed by individual circumstances, investment objectives, and risk preferences. While the British ISA may hold promise for some investors, it’s crucial to weigh its potential benefits against the broader landscape of tax-efficient savings options and consider seeking professional financial advice where necessary.

As the British ISA remains in the consultation phase, investors should stay informed about developments and carefully evaluate their options to ensure they make the most suitable choices to achieve their long-term financial objectives while remaining tax-efficient.