20 Mar, 2017
1.5 Americans in Asia could face gut-wrenching 'citizide' decision
More than half of Americans living in East Asia now have problems accessing normal banking services due to FATCA, America’s highly controversial global tax law, a new survey has revealed.
The poll, carried out by deVere Group, one of the world's largest independent organisations, and its Hong Kong division, Acuma, also discovered that FATCA is prompting nearly a fifth to consider giving up their U.S. passports and that 38% have experienced people and/or organisations not wanting to conduct business with and/or employ them thanks to the tax law.
More than 2,500 Americans resident in the East Asian powerhouse cities of Shanghai, Beijing, Hong Kong and Tokyo took part in the research.
deVere Group’s Head of East Asia, Doug Tucker, comments: “The Foreign Account Tax Compliance Act, or FATCA, has been a hammer blow to the 8 million Americans overseas since it was implemented in 2014.
"The results of this survey underscore FATCA's devastating effects on ordinary, hardworking U.S. citizens who happen to live and/or work abroad."
He continues: "FATCA was pushed through Congress by being flagged up as a way to combat serious tax evasion. Yet not one word of this flawed law actually tackles tax evasion activity.
"However, what it does do, is make life much, much harder for Americans outside the U.S. and American businesses operating internationally."
Under FATCA, all non-U.S. financial institutions, including banks, credit unions, insurance companies, investment and pension funds, are required to report the financial information of American clients who have accounts holding more than $50,000 directly to the IRS.
Mr Tucker goes on to say: "54% of those surveyed told us that they have experienced trouble opening and/or holding a bank account outside the U.S. since FATCA’s implementation. Non U.S. financial institutions now routinely refuse to handle American clients – even if they have been clients for years – as it is too much trouble and too costly to comply with FATCA’s onerous rules.
"Not having access to basic banking services, such as a checking account or mortgage, in your country of residence, clearly, makes life very difficult.
"Similarly, 38% have encountered difficulties in their professional life - for example, people not wanting to do business with them or considering them for employment - because they are an American. For example, an American might not be considered for a higher-level position which has signatory powers, because then their employers/organisation would also then have the FATCA burden thrust upon them."
He adds: "Bearing in mind the enormous unintended adverse consequences of FATCA, our survey in East Asia reveals that nearly a fifth (19% are saying that they are now reluctantly considering renouncing their U.S. citizenship.
“Extrapolated to the total number of expats, that amounts to more than 1.5m U.S. citizens facing this gut-wrenching decision. It is hardly surprising then that two-thirds of those polled want the Trump administration to repeal FATCA as a matter of urgency."
Official U.S. government figures echo deVere's findings, with a record – and increasing - number of Americans abroad giving up their passports since FATCA was enacted.
Recently, deVere Group CEO, Nigel Green, launched the Washington DC-based Campaign to Repeal FATCA, with veteran DC professional, former U.S. diplomat and long-time Senate leadership staffer, Jim Jatras.
Mr Tucker concludes: "FATCA has branded Americans overseas as financial lepers and is making life impossible. FATCA is, as Senator Rand Paul of Kentucky says, 'a textbook example of a bad law that doesn't achieve its stated purpose but does manage to unleash a host of unanticipated destructive consequences'
"It's time to repeal this damaging and highly controversial piece of legislation that has had the unintended consequence of disrupting the normal lives of law-abiding Americans based outside the States."
The primary survey questions:
Have you experienced trouble opening/holding a bank account outside the U.S. since FATCA was implemented?
Yes: 54 per cent No: 44 per cent Maybe: 2 per cent
Have you encountered difficulties in your professional life (for example, people not wanting to do business with you, or considering you for employment, etc.) because you are an American?
Yes: 38 per cent No: 58 per cent Maybe: 4 per cent
Are you in favour of FATCA’s repeal?
Yes: 64 per cent No: 21 per cent Maybe: 15 per cent
Would you consider renouncing your U.S. citizenship because of FATCA? If so, would FATCA’s repeal impact your decision?
Yes: 19 per cent No: 72 per cent Maybe: 9 per cent
Are you aware that there is language in Republican Platform calling for FATCA’s repeal?
Yes: 34 per cent No: 64 per cent Maybe: 2 per cent
Have you been in contact with any Senators or congressman regarding FATCA?
Yes: 7 per cent No: 92 per cent Maybe: 1 per cent
Would you consider getting involved with a campaign to get FATCA repeal passed by Congress and on the President’s desk?
Yes: 35 per cent No: 48 per cent Maybe: 17 per cent
Today's News - PM begins Brexit tour as Sturgeon eyes independence